Christmas…er…Holiday Stupidity


Borrowed from Whatever I Think. Click on the pic to check out her blog!

It’s Christmas time.  Really, it is, though in public government schools, among myriad other places, you wouldn’t know it.  Why?  Because Christmas, and any reference to it, is being systematically squelched.  It should amaze everyone that here, in 2012, in the freest nation on earth (well, at one time), we can’t publicly celebrate Christmas!  At least, we can’t anymore without some recrimination.  This has become one of the many things I hate about Christmas.  Where has the good will among men gone, because it surely is not widely evident, not even in the Christmas season when it should be modus operandi.

As I headed into the grocery store last week, I encountered one of the ubiquitous Salvation Army bell ringers.  He wished me Happy Holidays, and I responded with Merry Christmas.  He had the audacity to chide me for that (Really!!), telling me I ought to say Happy Holidays, that it was better…and safer…these days.  Better for whom?  Safer for whom?  And who cares!?  This stance that we have to curtail our Christmas spirit (or have it forcibly curtailed) is stupid and infuriating, and yet in so many cases we who celebrate Christmas just shrug our shoulders as if there’s nothing we can do, so why bother trying.

Did you catch the irony that the bell ringer is working for a Christian organization as a Christmas employee, during the Christmas season…the season of giving…and during the Salvation Army’s largest fundraising event of the year?!  I did, and I told him I did not believe in wishing Happy Holidays to everyone, when in fact I (and most others) are celebrating Christmas!  (What I didn’t say was that I didn’t appreciate being chided for Christmas greetings, and that if he was looking for donations, that was a really poor way to go about getting any.)  I did pass along my annoyance to the Salvation Army, however, and they (shockingly) responded…appropriately (to me), and (hopefully) appropriately to him.

Every single day I read or hear on the news about the latest assaults on Christmas.

  • No more Christmas trees…now they’re holidays trees.
  • Many places are banning Christmas holiday trees altogether.
  • Christmas carols?  Nope, holiday music, and definitely no religious carols.
  • Christmas shopping on Black Friday?  None that I saw.  Black Friday sales for holiday shopping.
  • Some schools have banned the kids from saying Merry Christmas.  What??  (First amendment, but I digress…)
  • No Christmas decorations…winter decorations, or generic holiday decorations.
  • Employers banning Christmas greetings.  WTH??

It goes on and on.  You can see the evidence of this even in Hollywood, with fewer Christmas movies coming out this year than in years past.  I don’t know about you, but I love Christmas movies:  Elf, A Christmas Story, National Lampoon’s Christmas Vacation, How the Grinch Stole Christmas…  They’re  like Christmas music for me – a way to capture the magic of the season for a moment, and to celebrate what should make Christmas the most wonderful time of the year.  They’re  a momentary escape from some of the rotten realities of the season…like this ongoing war against Christmas.

What is astonishing is how infrequent it is that those who are exposing all of this anti-Christmas foolishness are not pointing out time and time again – loudly – how no one is seeking to ban anyone else from celebrating their holiday of choice.  There is no movement to stifle Chanukah celebrations in this country.  No backlash against Kwanzaa.  No attempts to silence Ramadan observance.  If anything, these holidays are protected and preserved, as are those who celebrate them.  But Christmas…an official national holiday…is being silenced little by little, all in the name of fairness, equality, and the right to live unoffended.

Well, what about me?  It offends me to CENSOR Christmas.  It offends me that we have become a nation so over-sensitive to being offended that we stifle our own expressions of faith and joy lest we offend others who are expressing their faith and joy (publicly) in a different way.  It’s stupid!  It’s infuriating!  Perhaps most of all (and in my opinion), it seeks to devalue the real reason for Christmas to the point where there is barely a vestige of Christ left in Christmas.

Truly, what I wish is that Christmas…Christmas…CHRISTmas…would be valued more as a celebration of Jesus’ birth than a holiday for extravagance and decadence.  At the minimum, I wish that this ridiculous notion that those who celebrate differently are offended when Christmas is celebrated openly, publicly & joyfully would be put to rest.  It’s not the case…at least, not in this country, and we should not behave as though it is.

So, that’s how I am celebrating, and I’m starting by wishing you all a bold & joyous Merry Christmas!


8 thoughts on “Christmas…er…Holiday Stupidity

  1. “It should amaze everyone that here, in 2012, in the freest nation on earth (well, at one time), we can’t publicly celebrate Christmas! ”

    Sure you can.

    The government just can’t support it in a religious way.

    • I went on to say “At least we can’t anymore without recrimination.” Of course we can celebrate any way we choose, but Christians and others who celebrate Christmas are the ones whose holiday is routinely targeted. You don’t see that happening with any other. Don’t cherry pick to make your point.

      • We don’t see that happening with any other because no other religious group in America is trying to make the government promote their religion. This is not because they wouldn’t, and I’m not trying to pile on just Christianity. It’s because Christians are the majority. Not happy with just that, many of them want to get the government to religiously celebrate their holiday. Sorry, but that’s illegal.

        • You are misrepresenting my position. I do not seek to have the government promote my religion. Rather, I would like the government to BUTT OUT and let me (and other Christian) practice their religion – including holiday celebration – however they choose. That is a first amendment right, and the government violates it regularly when it censors religions expressions of Christmas cheer. The government is to neither establish a religion or hinder the free exercise of religion, and when all of these Christmas “regulations” are instituted by public officials, they are violating the free exercise portion of the first amendment. Sorry, but THAT’S illegal.

    • Every incident of schools forbidding any expression of Christmas, and there are plenty of news articles as evidence. Every incident where individuals are not permitted to decorate for Christmas in public spaces, and there are plenty of news articles on that as well. When the government censors speech & expression, it violates the first amendment. I am not going to give a laundry list of articles, as you are capable of googling for yourself. Obviously we are not prevented from doing as we wish in our homes and privately, but the government has no business censoring any free expression or free exercise of religion. It is against the law, and unconstitutional, and self explanatory. Why are you straining at gnats?

      • You do understand that public schools are run by the government? And when a public school (the school and employees, not the kids) promote a holiday religiously that is against the Constitution. If there have been children who have been punished for saying Christmas (which I doubt, but I could be wrong), then it’s because the school doesn’t understand the law.

        “for Christmas in public spaces”

        Again, if the government promotes it in government run spaces, that’s against the law. It depends what you mean by ‘public’.

  2. The 1st amendment specifically says this with regard to religion: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.

    Free expression is exactly that – free. It means that when individuals (which means we, the people) set up holiday decorations on public property that are religious in nature, we are freely exercising our religious beliefs. That is not government endorsement. It is NOT PROHIBITING the free exercise of religion.

    You can doubt all you want about government (public) schools prohibiting expressions of Christmas cheer, or anything else that overtly refers to Christmas, religious or otherwise. It happens every year, in many schools, and these incidents are publicized regularly by news outlets. This is a violation of the first amendment regarding both freedom of speech and the free exercise of religion (should students be inclined to express themselves religiously). No individual should be expected to check their constitutional rights at the door of any government institution, and yet it happens much more often than you want to admit.

    You keep spouting your talking points rather than comprehending what I am saying. You are not responding to my points, even when I clarified my statements and pointed out where you have misrepresented me; you just keep restating the same thing. As such, I don’t see the point in discussing this further.

Comments rock. Please leave yours!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s